SC upholds Razon takeover of PECO facilities


The Supreme Court has ruled in favor of the Enrique Razon-led MORE Electric Power Corp. to take over the assets of rival Panay Electric Company (PECO).

SC spokesperson Brian Keith Hosaka told reporters that the en banc voted 8-6 in favor of MORE Power.

“In granting the petitions, the Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Mandaluyong City Branch 209 in Civil Case No. R-MND-19-00571, and declared Section 10 and 17 of RA (Republic Act) No. 11212 constitutional,” said Hosaka.

Section 10 authorizes MORE to exercise the power of eminent domain and acquire such private property as is actually necessary for the realization of the purpose for which the franchise is granted.

Section 17 states the power of MORE, as grantee, to effectively acquire power distribution assets. The distribution assets that exist within the franchise area could only refer to those of PECO.

Immediately after President Rodrigo Duterte signed MORE Power’s franchise on February 14, 2019, PECO questioned RA 11212 before the Mandaluyong RTC.

In July 2019, Regional Trial Court Branch 209 Judge Monique Quisumbing-Ignacio ruled that PECO has no obligation to sell and MORE has no right to expropriate PECO’s assets under Sections 10 and 17 of RA 11212 and PECO’s rights to its properties are protected against arbitrary and confiscatory taking.

But MORE Power secured a temporary restraining order from the SC in December 2019.

Last February 28, the Iloilo Regional Trial Court Branch 23 allowed MORE to take over PECO’s assets.

In March 2020, the Energy Regulatory Commission granted MORE Power a provisional authority effectively revoking the certificate of public convenience and necessity given to PECO.

The Iloilo City government then revoked PECO’s business permit for lack of franchise and CPCN.